2 min read
Football Insider

Elliot Anderson or Adam Wharton: The Ideal Replacement for Casemiro at Man Utd?

Manchester United is in search of a new midfielder to replace the departing Casemiro, with former Red Devils star emphasizing the need for a player with 'personality'. Among the potential candidates are Elliot Anderson and Adam Wharton. Learn more about their prospects and why they could be vital additions to the team.

Elliot Anderson or Adam Wharton: The Ideal Replacement for Casemiro at Man Utd?

Elliot Anderson and Adam Wharton are the two players Manchester United should be targeting to replace Casemiro in the summer, according to a Champions League-winning former Red Devils' star. Casemiro has overcome fierce criticism to play a crucial role in United's unbeaten start under Michael Carrick, although his resurgent displays have not been enough to earn him a new contract.United considered signing a midfielder last summer but ultimately decided to focus on renewing their attack, spending more than £200m bringing in Bryan Mbeumo, Matheus Cunha and Benjamin Sesko, in addition to goalkeeper Senne Lammens. The engine room was always going to be their main area of focus ahead of next season but their search for a new midfielder is even more urgent now that Casemiro is departing. The Brazilian instantly bolstered the Red Devils when he joined for £70m from Real Madrid in 2022 after they had made a nightmare start to the season under new boss Erik ten Hag. Casemiro helped United finish third that season and win the Carabao Cup but he endured a punishing second campaign, leading to Jamie Carragher to declare his time at the top level was up. Casemiro has staged an impressive turnaround in the last year, giving United a daunting task in finding a replacement for the five-time Champions League winner and captain of Brazil.Former United midfielder Owen Hargreaves has praised Casemiro for proving critics like Carragher wrong after receiving "disrespect that has been off the scale". And he believes Nottingham Forest midfielder Anderson is the leading candidate to replace Casemiro at Old Trafford.TNT Sports pundit Hargreaves told GOAL: "Adam Wharton is a really good player. So smart, sees the game a bit quicker than most players. He plays first time passes, but Elliot's a different profile. You know, Elliot's a bit bigger, probably a bit more aggressive, so I think they're both super talented young players."I think Elliot probably has the nod just right now, because he's probably a little bit more physical but I think Adam is a kid who could play with anyone because he's so smart."Hargreaves compared Anderson to Declan Rice and he believes the former Newcastle midfielder, who has been partnering Rice in England's midfield since September, has the character to succeed at United. "He reminds me a bit of Declan in the sense that he's been given opportunities and he’s running with it. As a young player, he's developing at a rapid speed and getting better all the time. He’s got size, got skill, got everything. The thing I like about Elliot is he seems to have a personality. "And that's what you need when it's hard, because it's not so much about being a good player. It's like, can you deal with the expectation of playing for club like Man United? That's one of the things you don't know, something you don't see on data and scouting reports. He looks like he's got a drive."Anderson will be hoping to help Forest beat Wolves on Wednesday in a crucial match in their bid to avoid relegation. It is one of 10 Premier League games this week that is being shown live on TNT Sports.Also on Wednesday, Manchester City host Fulham looking to capitalise on their incredible comeback win over Liverpool, who will be hoping to pick up the pieces from their late collapse when they visit Sunderland. Meanwhile, Crystal Palace host Burnley and Aston Villa will play at home to Brighton and Hove Albion.Then, on Thursday, Premier League leaders Arsenal visit Brentford.Add GOAL.com as a preferred source on Google to see more of our reportingBenjamin Sesko preserved Carrick's unbeaten start with United by snatching a 1-1 draw at West Ham with a 96th-minute equaliser. It was the Slovenian international's second last-gasp goal in three games after scoring a 94th-minute winner against Fulham. He has scored seven goals in total since his £74m move from RB Salzburg last summer although he is yet to start a game under Carrick.Hargreaves praised Carrick's handling of Sesko, pointing out that United have always slowly bedded in young forwards rather than throwing them straight in at the deep end. He explained: "I think the best thing to do for a young player like that, even though you paid a lot of money for him, is to let him watch and learn. That's what they used to do back in the day, 10 years ago. You know, a guy like Sesko would have been the fourth striker at a big club. The prime Manchester United had Cristiano Ronaldo, Wayne Rooney and Ole Gunnar Solskjaer. [Before then] Teddy Sheringham, Andy Cole and Dwight Yorke. "And you would have had a young guy learning the ropes. We had that with Danny Welbeck. He was coming through, he was 18 and he was probably our fifth striker when we won the league. He trained with us every day and he learned so much. To throw him in at 18 or 19 or 20 years old like they did with Marcus Rashford, Anthony Martial and Rasmus Hojlund, who has now gone, I don't think it's good for their development. "When the club's not doing well, they take all the pressure. And I think having Sesko and saying 'Just watch from the side, come on for the last 25 minutes and you'll get your chances....' And look, it's not a coincidence that he's thriving. I know agents and players say 'I want to play, I want to play.' Well, you might not be ready for it. So [Carrick is saying] 'Learn the ropes, I'll help you. I've been there for 20 years, I've seen this, just trust me'. And it's working."

1

Former Red Devils Star's Recommendation

As Manchester United prepares to part ways with Casemiro, former Red Devils midfielder Owen Hargreaves has highlighted the importance of finding a replacement with a strong personality. Hargreaves believes that Nottingham Forest midfielder Elliot Anderson is the leading candidate to fill the void left by Casemiro's departure. He commended Anderson for his physicality, likening him to the likes of Declan Rice and emphasizing the importance of his character in adapting to the demands of playing for a club like Manchester United.

2

The Rising Stars: Elliot Anderson and Adam Wharton

Elliot Anderson and Adam Wharton emerge as promising talents on the radar of Manchester United. While Wharton is praised for his intelligence and quick decision-making on the field, Anderson's physical presence and evolving skill set make him a compelling option for the Red Devils. Hargreaves' endorsement of Anderson's potential to thrive under the pressure of a top club adds further weight to the argument for considering him as the primary choice to reinforce United's midfield.

3

Strategic Approach to Young Talent: The Case of Benjamin Sesko

In light of Benjamin Sesko's impactful contributions off the bench, Owen Hargreaves underlines the significance of nurturing young talents like Sesko through a gradual integration process. Drawing parallels to past Manchester United forwards who benefited from learning alongside established stars, Hargreaves advocates for a patient approach to developing emerging prospects. By allowing Sesko to observe and learn before thrusting him into the starting lineup, Michael Carrick's management style has proven instrumental in nurturing the Slovenian forward's growth and performance.

4

Looking Ahead: Potential Signings and Crucial Matches

With the impending departure of Casemiro, Manchester United faces the task of bolstering their midfield with a suitable replacement. As the transfer window approaches, the club's pursuit of Anderson or Wharton could shape their future dynamics on the pitch. In the meantime, key Premier League fixtures, including Nottingham Forest's clash with Wolves and Manchester City's challenge against Fulham, offer additional intrigue and excitement for football enthusiasts to follow.

Published on Feb 11, 2026